Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is my work in GitLaw covered by legal privilege?
GitLaw is not a law firm, so what you type to GitLaw's AI is not protected by attorney-client privilege on its own. Privilege comes from your relationship with a lawyer, not from the software.
If you are a lawyer, keeping client documents in GitLaw works like keeping them in any other confidential cloud tool. Your files stay private to you and the people you share them with, subject to the access described below, and the AI providers we use do not train on them.
Courts are still deciding how privilege applies to AI tools, and the answers differ by court and by country. This article explains where things stand. It is not legal advice.
If you are not sure whether privilege applies in your situation, speak to a lawyer. You can use Find lawyer to be introduced to one.
What is legal privilege?
Privilege keeps confidential communications between a lawyer and their client out of the hands of the other side in a dispute.
- In the US, "attorney-client privilege" protects confidential communications between you and your lawyer about legal advice. A related protection, "work product", covers material prepared for litigation.
- In England and Wales (Scotland has similar rules), it is called "legal professional privilege" and is divided into two types: "legal advice privilege" protects confidential communications between you and your lawyer made for the dominant purpose of giving or receiving legal advice; and "litigation privilege" protects confidential communications and material prepared for the dominant purpose of adversarial legal proceedings (such as a court case) that are underway or reasonably in prospect.
For attorney-client privilege and legal advice privilege, three things usually have to be true:
- a lawyer is involved
- the communication is about legal advice
- it has been kept confidential.
Are my chats with GitLaw's AI privileged?
No, not on their own. GitLaw is legal AI, not a lawyer, and using it does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and GitLaw. A conversation with an AI is not a conversation with a lawyer, so it does not meet the first test.
That does not make your work public. Your documents and chats stay private to you and the people you share them with, subject to the access described below. Private and privileged are different things:
- a private document can still be requested in a lawsuit
- a privileged one generally cannot
Like any service provider, GitLaw can be required by law to disclose content, for example under a court order.
I'm a lawyer. Does putting client documents into GitLaw waive privilege?
No, using a confidential tool to do client work does not, as a general rule, waive privilege. Lawyers already rely on cloud email, document storage and e-signature providers on this basis. What matters is whether confidentiality is kept.
What GitLaw does to keep confidentiality:
- Private by default. Files are visible only to you and the people you invite. Inside an organisation, its Owner can also reach every file, so keep a sensitive matter in an organisation only you own.
- No AI training. Our AI providers do not train their models on your documents or chats.
- Zero data retention. Our AI providers do not store your content after processing it.
- Separate workspaces. You can create an organisation per client so matters stay apart.
- Limited staff access. AI conversations are logged in GitLaw's own monitoring system so we can debug and improve the service. A small number of GitLaw staff can access those logs. In limited cases set out in our Terms, such as security or legal compliance, staff may also access other content.
You remain responsible for deciding whether GitLaw meets your professional obligations. Full details are in our Privacy Policy and Terms, which take priority if anything here differs.
As of November 2026 we are not aware of a court ruling on a lawyer using a confidential legal AI platform like GitLaw. The cases we cite below involve people using public consumer chatbots on their own.
What have the courts said so far?
Two US federal courts ruled on the same day in February 2026 and reached different results.
| Case | What happened | Result |
|---|---|---|
| United States v. Heppner (S.D.N.Y., 10 Feb 2026) | A criminal defendant ran queries through the public version of Claude on his own, without direction from his lawyer | Not privileged and not work product. The AI is not an attorney, and the tool's privacy terms allowed disclosure to third parties |
| Warner v. Gilbarco (E.D. Mich., 10 Feb 2026) | A plaintiff representing herself used ChatGPT to prepare her case | Protected as work product. The court called AI programs "tools, not persons" and found no waiver |
Neither case decided what happens when a lawyer directs the AI use, or when the tool has negotiated confidentiality protections. The Heppner court suggested the answer could be different where counsel directs the work.
Since then, several US courts have followed Warner, including Morgan v. V2X (D. Colo., Mar 2026) and Tate Group Automotive (Tex. Bus. Ct., Jun 2026). In England and Wales, a tribunal (in UK v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] UKUT 81 (IAC)) has commented that putting confidential information into public AI tools could waive privilege. Those comments are not binding, and we are not aware of a binding ruling in England and Wales.
This is a new and developing area of law, and the position may change.
Source: Cleary Gottlieb, Courts Grapple with Privilege Implications of AI (27 Feb 2026).
Later decisions: Gunster on Morgan v. V2X, Haynes Boone on the Texas Business Court decision, Crowell, AI privilege case tracker and Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer on the Upper Tribunal decision (Mar 2026).
What do the bar rules say about lawyers using AI?
ABA Formal Opinion 512 (29 July 2024) says lawyers can use generative AI if they protect client confidentiality. It requires the client's informed consent before confidential information goes into a self-learning tool, meaning one that trains on what users enter. Boilerplate in an engagement letter is not enough for that consent.
GitLaw's AI providers do not train on your content. Lawyers are still expected to understand a tool's terms and confidentiality protections before using it. State bars have their own rules, so check the guidance where you are licensed.
Source: Frankfurt Kurnit summary of ABA Formal Opinion 512.
I'm not a lawyer. How do I keep privilege when working with one?
- Talk to the lawyer directly. Privilege protects your confidential communications with a lawyer about legal advice, which usually includes a first consultation.
- Let your lawyer direct the work. Material you prepare because your lawyer asked for it stands on firmer ground than material you prepare on your own.
- Keep legal advice out of public chatbots. Pasting your lawyer's advice into a consumer AI tool can put its confidentiality at risk.
- Share narrowly. Invite your lawyer to the document or organisation they need, and nobody who does not need it.
Does privilege apply when I use Find lawyer?
Not at the request stage. Your request goes through GitLaw's Concierge (GitLaw staff and systems) before it reaches a lawyer, so keep the detail to what is needed for matching. Privilege typically covers what you tell the lawyer directly, not the request that passes through GitLaw.